Support #1231
open
Percentage of young people living with their parents in England
100%
Description
Hi,
I found the percentage of young people (aged 20-34 years old in each wave) living with their parents in UKHLS is inconsistent with the percentage in Labour Force Survey.
I used n_npns_dv to derive whether young graduates are living with their parents. I used cross-sectional weight n_indpxub_xw (I also tried longitudinal weight) to adjust the sample. My case study is in England.
I found that the percentage of young people living with their parents rose from 25% in wave 1 to 46% in wave 8. However, in the LFS, this figure was also 25% in 2009 but only 28% in 2018. Not sure if I can do anything to close this 18% gap.
Many thanks.
Louise
Files
Updated by Alita Nandi over 5 years ago
- Status changed from New to In Progress
- Private changed from Yes to No
Hi Louise,
We are looking into this issue and will get back to you soon.
Best wishes,
Alita
Updated by Stephanie Auty
Updated by Louise Luo over 5 years ago
Hi Alita,
I check the figures using longitudinal weight (indpxnub_lw) in a balanced panel today. I found the percentage of young people living with parents dropped from 41% in 2012 to 23% in 2017. This seems to be controversial to that indicated in https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/families/articles/whyaremoreyoungpeoplelivingwiththeirparents/2016-02-22 .
Best,
Louise
Updated by Alita Nandi over 5 years ago
- File w1_project_instructions.pdf w1_project_instructions.pdf added
- Assignee set to Louise Luo
- % Done changed from 10 to 50
Hello Louise,
Sorry for the delay in getting back to you. Our team has looked at the ONS report you are referring to and our data. Here are some possible reasons for the difference you found:
1) In the ONS table notes, it is mentioned “Once a person either lives with a partner or has a child, they are considered to have formed their own family and are no longer counted as being part of their parents’ family even if they still live in the same household*. Therefore such people are deemed to be not living with their parents here.” -> which leads to the conclusion that LFS figures might underestimate the proportion of young people living with parents as, for example, lone parents (mostly single mothers), or multigenerational households would not be taken into account. So, see if after using the LFS definition of household and applying that to our data, the difference in proportions of 20-34 year olds living with their parents across the two surveys reduces.
*See page 40 of the attached document to see how households are defined in our study
2) Other things to take into consideration from the notes under the tables “Students living in halls of residence during term-time and living with their parents outside term-time are counted as not living with their parents here.” In UKHLS, some young people are enumerated in household grid (indall file) but could indeed live most of the year elsewhere (e.g. in the student halls).
3) There may be differential attrition with young people living with their parents less likely to attrit (when people move the risk of losing contact with them increases).
Hope this helps. If you have further questions or follow-up please let us know.
Best wishes,
Alita
Updated by Louise Luo over 5 years ago
Hi Alita,
Thanks for your reply.
Best wishes,
Louise
Updated by Understanding Society User Support Team almost 4 years ago
- Status changed from In Progress to Resolved
- Assignee deleted (
Louise Luo) - % Done changed from 50 to 100